Western democracies are going through a delicate phase. The loss of momentum among political parties, a certain distrust of institutions, and declining civic engagement all point to this situation. Without delving into detailed analysis, the current context- marked by sudden changes, extreme complexity, and fundamental challenges - is putting pressure on political systems based on dialogue and compromise, which are often perceived as slow and cumbersome in the face of an increasingly fast-paced world.
However, it is not only politics and institutions that are being called into question. Traditional media - which are essential for the development of critical thinking and the formation of opinions through the dissemination of verified news - are also notoriously struggling, with declining readership, audiences, and resources being siphoned off by social media platforms. These platforms fuel and contribute to the spirit of the times. They encourage immediacy, divisive trends, and viral phenomena - all of which are at odds with that hard-won compromise born of democratic debate. Today, generative artificial intelligence has joined the fray, presenting yet another challenge.
The influence of digital technology on democratic processes has become increasingly significant. There is no shortage of cases where elections have been marred by the massive and pernicious intrusion into the debate of false content and bots published at a rapid pace on social media. Less striking examples, however, can be found on a daily basis, when distorted news - even if not intended maliciously - gains the status of truth through a snowball effect due to the absence of appropriate mediation. These are dangerous trends for democratic societies.
It is also in light of these transformations that the State Secretariat for Education, Research, and Innovation (SERI) has dedicated the second update of the report “Citizenship Education in Switzerland – An Overview” to the key competencies needed to address disinformation.
“We often think of disinformation as simply a problem of fake news. In reality, the stakes are higher, because it concerns the way we participate in democratic life.” Andrea Plata is a senior lecturer and researcher at the Competence Centre for Innovation and Research on Education Systems (CIRSE) at the DFA/ASP. He has also long been a member of the Commission on Education for Democracy at the SUPSI department in Locarno. Together with him, we’ll explore the key points highlighted in the SERI report.
“Today, we also get our information through digital platforms and AI-based tools that offer many opportunities but also make it harder to navigate. That’s why it’s not enough to simply ask whether a piece of content is true or false. We need to understand where the information comes from, how it’s disseminated, and what interests or motivations might influence its circulation. Learning to compare sources, distinguish facts from opinions, and engage in dialogue with those who hold different views is essential for forming an independent opinion and participating in democratic life in an informed and conscious manner. In my view, this is, in a way, the message that emerges from the SERI report.”
In the photos: International Day of Democracy 2025
To protect democratic principles from disinformation and promote active citizenship, the education system plays a fundamental role. In this regard, the SERI report notes that, although approaches vary depending on the curriculum, Switzerland has a solid foundation - one that should not, however, be taken for granted. The digital environment changes much more rapidly than school curricula and educational institutions, while platforms, algorithms, and generative AI are constantly introducing new forms of manipulation and new information behaviors.
“The Ticino compulsory education curriculum already offers important points of reference. On the one hand, the cross-curricular competency ‘Technology and Media’ aims to develop in students a critical and informed approach to digital technologies and media; on the other hand, ‘Civic Education, Citizenship, and Democracy’ addresses issues related to democratic participation and public life. In my view, the challenge today lies in fostering greater dialogue between these two areas. I believe it is important to give students the opportunity to work on concrete cases, critically analyze sources and content circulating online, and create opportunities for them to engage in discussion, dialogue, reasoning, and participation. Achieving this requires time, interdisciplinary collaboration, and professional development opportunities for teachers.”
The report also notes that teacher training remains inconsistent, particularly with regard to teaching methods and the citizenship skills needed to address disinformation.
“Fortunately, there is a nationwide debate in Switzerland on these issues, and it is true that training models vary. In recent years, significant strides have been made at the DFA/ASP. Attention to and awareness of democracy and citizenship education have increased thanks to various projects and initiatives, such as International Democracy Day, the ‘Democracy and School’ series, and various applied research projects aimed at developing teaching materials, such as Tedyc or Swiss-Inca. Our colleagues at the Media and MINT Laboratory (MEM) are also doing excellent work in research and training, among other things, on the topics of information and media literacy. In the Departmental Action Plan, currently in effect, global citizenship education - which includes measures that explicitly address, among other areas, peace and democracy education as well as media, technology, and AI education - is a priority.”
The school system can certainly provide the foundations and tools, offer activities, and impart the skills needed to distinguish verified information from fake news, but that alone is not enough. Adequate information - and, by extension, citizenship education - requires the collaboration of various stakeholders, including those outside the school walls.
“That is absolutely true. The activities promoted by youth organizations, associations, municipalities, museums, and the media offer important opportunities to experience citizenship outside of school. In the projects we develop together with schools and the local community, young people can participate in decisions on issues that directly affect them, often in collaboration with adults. These experiences help them understand how important it is to listen to and accept viewpoints different from their own, seeking consensus through reasoned argument. These are projects that also allow students to grapple with a less immediate aspect of democracy: collective decisions must take into account diverse interests and real constraints. Participation, therefore, means seeking shared solutions, knowing that not all of one’s proposals will be accepted. In projects such as “Fiume Spazio Tempo” at the Parco delle Gole della Breggia, or “Orto Orto Orto” in the municipality of Stabio, this aspect emerges very clearly.”
For reasons related to its mandate, the report focuses primarily on young people in education. But vulnerability to disinformation certainly does not end with school.
“It is important to invest in young people and their education. This means offering them the tools to understand the world in which they live, take a stand, and help improve or change it. But we cannot place the entire burden on future generations. Citizenship education concerns all adults,” concludes Plata.